A Certain Magical Index #11 — Railgun? Who?

December 11th, 2009

 

I remember this show.

Impressions:

Oh hey, an ‘action’ episode that is filled with flashbacks, people explaining their powers, preaching, and every single character is on the rag. It’s like I’m watching the worst parts of Index once again, only this time, instead of Touma punching somebody to prove his point, Mikoto hugs them and drags us into a 9 minute flashback. CALL ME UNDERWHELMED. What’s wrong with wanting ultimate power? I’ll take a 20 second "I’m crazy as a march hare" monologue over blowing half the episode doling out some generic motivation to be eeeeevil.

Blah blah blah, Kiriyama was made to experiment on little kids by giant jerks and that makes her sad, so this whole thing was to figure out what the hell happened. Oops. I just ruined 50% of the episode for you. Enjoy the remaining 4 minutes of exposition about how many abilities people peoples have, three minutes of Mikoto preaching or talking about her powers, three minutes of deus ex software, and one minute of actual action, most of which consisted of them throwing CG at each other… and 15 seconds of evil super-network fetus.

I can’t wait for them to try to talk to it for another 10 minutes next week.

Preview:

I bet they already showed all of next week’s action in the preview.

Posted in Railgun | 14 Comments »

14 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • Forte says:

    “I bet they already showed all of next week’s action in the preview.”

    Haahahahaha. LOOKS NICE, LOOKS NICE!

  • Rei says:

    “I bet they already showed all of next week’s action in the preview.”
    What’s…… with the tentacle -____-||||

  • Lero says:

    Hey! what the hell is Yomikawa doing there?

  • TJ says:

    Well, at least the action wasn’t bad. the flashback was a tad long though

  • redlupine says:

    Looks like Mikoto will be fighting the final boss from Parasite Eve.

  • Celestial says:

    COMPLETE BREAKDOWN

    AN INSTITUTE

    FETUS ATTAKKKKUUU

  • Shinji103 says:

    The flashback was indeed long and certainly felt way longer than the manga version. But just as I see people doing with Index, people are overblowing the “bad-ness” of exposition and preaching, two things that are there in almost every action anime. Bleach, Rurouni Kenshin, Gundam, etc. etc.; they all have preachiness, and even Gundam has a bit of exposition. One of the few animes I know that doesn’t have exposition (and it still had preachiness) was Night Wizard, only because it didn’t have big, complicated powers to explain like standing on walls with electricity. It just had swords or big beam cannons.

    If the flashback hadn’t been so needlessly long, the exposition and “preachiness” wouldn’t have felt like such a big part of the episode, so it was the flashback that did the damage.

  • Meh says:

    I actually thought this episode was real solid. Compared to some of the crap that Index tried to push on us, this actually worked out a hell of a lot smoother, way more understandable, and the fight I thought was well choreographed. You were too hard on this Arudoc. Compare this to the second to last index episode, and tell me which was worse.

    • Aroduc says:

      Given where both made it to by their respective episode 11s, that’s not exactly promising for Railgun.

  • albert_2mb says:

    This is why I love the manga more. I mean, I could blaze through the flashbacks and expositions in just seconds, while in the anime…

    Animated saten-san is one of the few reasons I still like the anime.

  • Nanaya says:

    Again, I *really* hope they won’t do the whole final-attack-OP-insert-song, but I have a bad feeling they will. For some reason that destroys any immersion I had, completely messes the scene up for me. Call it a pet peeve I guess.

  • iRathiest says:

    Read the manga. Then watch the opener for the next episode. You’ll understand why I couldn’t stop laughing for a good 20 minutes.

    Or maybe you won’t. Whatever.

    My abdomen still hurts, by the way.

  • Rawr says:

    Well, Canaan was a purely action oriented anime with crap plot, and we all know how that one turned out. While I agree that Index and Railgun tend to have tedious monologues and scientific explanations, I don’t think this episode was badly done. The action, while cg was hardly cringe worthy. You can bash cg done badly, but why the hell bash cg done right?

    I also liked the flash back. I didn’t realy pay attention to the length either. I’m probably biased towards this episode though because I like Kiyama as a character. Since for some weird freaking reason I find a 30 year old woman with droopy eyes and a stripping tendency to be more moe than all the other blobs in this show.

  • Newprimus says:

    LOL they downgraded the Lamborghini Reventon in the manga into a scissor-doored Gallardo, hahahahaa.

    Still, what kind of research scientist makes enough money to own a lambo? Yeesh, you baggy-eyed exhibitionist woman!