天下制覇

Hayate says:

That’s basically correct.

Shiki is just the first names to the two. And their last names tended to belong to particular clans.

The Ryougi Clan was a special clan that required a special trait to lead the family. Ryougi in this case had it while her brother didn’t. The special trait was the so called split personality that she had where she had one female personality and one male personality in her. The usage of the Japanese language dialect used by either personality was different in terms of how girls or how boys used it.

The Nanaya Clan was a special clan whose blood would react to those with unnatural powers or ‘demons’ in a sense. Their job was to basically exterminate them, the training and eventual taking of that destined job would leave them as cold-blooded killers.

Now that’s out of the way.

The Mystic Eyes of Death, came coincidentally through what seemed to be near death-ish like experiences. Shiki Tohno with his brush of death after getting stabbed in the chest. Shiki Ryougi getting hit by a car and forced into a coma. However, there is one catch. The two have different forms of the same mystic eyes.

Supposedly Ryougi has what seems to be the true Mystic Eyes of Death where she doesn’t require having to trace lines, but rather cut along one straight line. Like Shiki Tohno, she’s able to determine abnormalities in the body and stop them or cut through object. Though she is able to fully control when or when not to use the eyes. Also she’s able to cut through attacks of opposing Mystic Eyes users.

Shiki Tohno’s is a variant of the skill, where he would see black lines and dots. In one sense, you can also considering it being slightly more specific than Ryougi’s. Shiki’s Mystic Eyes are always on, and he initally can only see lines. However after one event, he then has the ability to see the lines and dots, however almost to the point where he was driven into an insane moment where his Nanaya blood almost took him over. Forced to wear glasses given by Aoko Aozaki.

Both users are able to ‘instantly kill’ their opponent in one strike. Ryougi can doing it naturally as she was fully trained. Shiki on the other hand requires him somewhat ‘losing’ himself to his Nanaya blood to get that level of skill, also Shiki requires him actually striking at a specific dot he sees.

Supposedly Shiki is slightly more powerful than Ryougi in terms of raw power. But Ryougi beats Shiki in pure skill until Shiki goes into his Nanaya state.

The only reason why there would be a possible link between the two series is because of the sisters, Touko Aozaki and Aoko Aozaki. Aoko steals the glasses or at least the materials for the glasses from Touko. Aoko is refered to as Ms. Blue in the magicians community, a title that Touko wanted. Touko absolutely is on bad terms with her sister, to the point of killing it seems. Since Aoko tends to travel around, the likelihood of them meeting is low. In terms of power between the two sisters. Aoko has destructive magic skills that make her a difficult opponent, while Touko’s intellect and cunning has a better advantage.

(That went longer than it should have….)

Hayate says:

Oh yeah, just to elaborate on the possible further of ‘what would happen if both Shiki’s had met the other through some random occurance.’ Based on their current standings and personalities.

Ryougi meets with Shiki, however she has no desire to associate with him even though he has similiar Mystic Eyes. Ryougi, works on a “I’ll kill you since you seem similiar or the same to me” type protocol. Unlike Shiki, who doesn’t want to really fight until absolutely necessary, Ryougi likes to kill and fight whenever she pleases. Ryougi’s third personality, the personality that reacts to the whole loss of the male personality, would simply regard Shiki as someone who just looks like Kokutou(Ryougi’s technical love interest of sorts but doesn’t show it much or even at all) but doesn’t care too much about besides Touko using him. There is a chance that if those two met, Touko would like to meet him out of curiousity of having the same kind of Mystic Eyes but different forms, then find out about the glasses because she’ll recognize the material it is made of, as well as it was hers, and likely ask who gave them to him. Which could in turn cause Touko to go into this slight ‘I’m still going to kill Aoko.’ mode while interrogating Shiki about where Aoko is with no success. As an added note Shiki wouldn’t react and go into Nanaya mode to either Ryougi or Touko because they’re not of the abnormal blood types or ‘demons.’ Shiki might react to the familiar that Touko has in her suitcase, but not to the point where he ‘loses’ himself to kill.

Battle Moon Wars does a fairly decent job on a what if setting when they had the Kara no Kyoukai and Tsukihime characters meeting up in one path sense.

Slightly out of order but, Ryougi’s desire to kill is usually based on what she senses or sees in her target. Either she just kills for the hell of it, which hasn’t happened after the accident. Ryougi’s current desire to kill just basically stems from her past experience, however it somewhat changed to people she probably would not like or with people with the same ‘killing’ manner as her in a sense. Shiki has a killing instinct because of his blood, but his general personality is what prevents him from fully becoming a Nanaya. Which in turns both lets him avoid being a target of Ryougi, as well Ryougi showing slight possible disgust or annoyance at him depending on the situation.

I find Touko’s taboo a bit interesting because it is kinda funny since she wanted to be refer to as Ms. Blue not as Ms. Red. Calling her Red is asking for immediate death by her and her familiar once said.

And to settle slightly who would win a fight between Ryougi and Shiki.

By technicality. Ryougi would win with her skill, speed, her ‘doll’ arm which should be stronger than a human’s, and her desire to kill without remorse or mercy. Shiki would try and defend himself as best as he can, however in terms of speed which he is a bit fast but not as fast as Ryougi. Ryougi’s speed and inhuman like ability due to her early training already from the get go can kill Shiki within maybe a few moves or so depending how well Shiki can defend himself while reading the lines. However as noted, whenever Shiki goes into Nanaya mode, the skill difference is very minute and the speed is near the same. Nanaya mode Shiki can match Ryougi blow for blow, however there is one catch. Nanaya Shiki can come up with things that Ryougi wouldn’t think of which could decide the match in crtical moments. Not to mention that Nanaya Shiki also uses his own hands as personal weapons to attack at any lines or points he sees which gives him a lot of variety.

Though in general. Ryougi vs Shiki(Normal) = Ryougi’s win. Ryougi vs Shiki(Nanaya) = either win based on situation, luck, and opportunity. Though one can argue that Shiki(Normal) could win as well is only determined if he doesn’t lose to his Nanaya blood, but accepts it and does what he did to Arcueid during their first meeting which is what we liked to call his ’17 Point Disection’ attack which he can instantly cause 17 disecting strikes all in one instance. Though likelihood of that is REALLY low because he needs a blood reaction from something abnormal first.