Shakugan no Shana S #01 — Girl Meets Girl

October 22nd, 2009

 

Okay, now I’m tired of Shana.

Impressions:

This was supposed to fill in missing things to connect season 2 and 3? Uh. If you insist, JCStaff.

I’m sure it was meant to be a comedy episode, but instead it barely felt any different from any of the show’s other bad filler episodes. They find a spazzy hougu that switches Shana and Yuuji’s bodies, and then instead of just admitted the problem and solving it, they instead run around and get into every cliche joke that you can think of. I’m pretty sure Kasimashi and Otoboku covered most of the same jokes that were in this episode within about 5 minutes. We have the "wrong bathroom," the "boy complains about wearing a skirt and panties," the "boy-as-girl acts really cute and stuns someone," the good ol’ "Omigod, I have a naked girl body" shower fantasy, and then ending with the almost more cliche "your hearts were connected all along." Thank you, Wizard of Oz, I should have known that we’d just need to click our heels and we could go back home.

It was okay, I guess, but didn’t really have too much aside from Yuuji-as-Shana blushing and acting flustered and struck me as mostly just an excuse for some out of character fanservice pandering. I’ve seen pretty much every single on of these jokes before and it added absolutely nothing in the way of development for the plot or any character, so I can’t help but wonder what exactly the point of this was.

There is a new OP, but my laptop would take about 40 minutes to encode it, so it ain’t happening. It’s just Shana running around in the rain anyway.

Posted in Shana | 9 Comments »

9 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • Smirk says:

    While watching, I couldn’t help smirking and grinning throughout this entire episode. It was amusing. And Alastor’s reaction and lines were gold.

    Even though it’s OOC, it was a decent plot device to have them act in a way they normally don’t.

  • Celestial says:

    slow de arimasu

  • Tokkan says:

    This episode actually takes place between seasons 1 and 2. It was a sidestory included with the first Shana artbook “Guren”. It really didn’t add much, it was written pretty much for fanservice. The other stories they have planned for Shana S (Zoetrope, Ceremony, Domicile) actually do add some development.

  • Hayate Yagami says:

    Say what you will, but I certainly LOLed through it.

  • Shinji103 says:

    http://blog.seiha.org/images2/shanas1/shanas1_69.jpg

    Saynowwhathere? O.o

    I could last through a whole ridiculous episode of nada just to see this scene. :D Did it actually happen and go through?

  • Lero says:

    This body swap didn’t happened in Index chaper 15?? since i already saw that I didn’t “enjoyed” this one.

  • Kurizu says:

    since it was a ova i enjoyed it had it been the opener for the 3rd season i would have smacked a bitch

  • kiri says:

    I enjoyed watching this =))

  • […] Kuro­gane animé blog:http://kurogane.animeblogger.net/2009/10/22/shakugan-no-shana-s/ Tenka Seiha:http://blog.seiha.org/2009/10/shakugan-no-shana-s-girl-meets-girl/ Charleston’s Opin­ion :Based on famous light novel,Shakugan no Shana has very com­plex story […]