Student Council Officers #05 — 5:40

August 1st, 2010

 

That’s how long it took for them to make their first actual joke.

Impressions:

You would think a comedy would have jokes, but apparently not. Maybe if you’re a blithering idiot, you couldn’t figure out within the first couple seconds that the GIANT FOGGY VIDEO OVERLAY meant either dream or flashback, and with the latter out of the way the first time anybody opened their mouth, that left dream. Which then proceeded for another 100 seconds before the stunning reveal that… it was a dream. That’s it. No other punchline. Just a dream. In fact, it was clear this week that GoHand’s writers have already pissed off down to the pub and left a panda at the typewriter. The first half was the biggest collection of bad cliches and recycled jokes that I’ve seen in years. Oh, Shino’s giving him a book. Just like last time. And it’s a porn book again. Just like last time. It’s even funnier the second time, especially strung out. Omigawd, a girl’s in his room, it must be to have sex. Omigawd, I hear noises, they must be having sex (in a very uncomfortable place). Yes. Great. Repetition makes everything better.

The second half of the episode didn’t exactly excel in the writing department either, but in a completely different way. It wa abundantly obvious that they were taking random jokes and just throwing them all together without any regard for… well… anything. It was like watching a bad stand-up comedy routine on stage, complete with the interstitial providing the rimshot signalling that the joke has been made and you are expected to laugh. Some of them were okay, but again, there was absolutely no rhythm, flow, or even cohesion between anything. It literally felt like they took the dregs from the cutting floor of previous episodes and dumped them all together, then wandered off.

Preview:

Breasts are not trampolines.

Posted in Student Council | 11 Comments »

11 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • Supramax says:

    Aroduc’s ranting about how bad the episode was, is more fun the the entire series so far.

  • Sporklord says:

    The premise was interesting for about 2 episodes, minus the introduction bits, but LOL PERVERT GIRLS only works for so long.

    I’m surprised the guy hasn’t lost it, for all the time he sits around these girls talking about sex.

  • RaiKitsune says:

    If the man had more balls he would enjoy the girls perverse nature. Also, this show has always been just random jokes and nothing else. You are kind of late figuring this out it seems.

    • Aroduc says:

      The bigger issue is consistency. Most of the time, there is an overarching narrative that ties the jokes together and lets them flow from one to the next organically. But then they abruptly drop that entirely and begin jumping between settings, times, and characters just to take the “throw a bowl of spaghetti at the fridge and see what sticks” approach, which has all the subtlety and lasting impact of throwing spaghetti.

      Random jokes on their own aren’t the problem. It’s that the show is making it painfully obvious that it’s just tossing completely disparate stuff together without even trying to make any of it fit.

      • Anise Punter says:

        This is the part where Shino wonders aloud what you could possibly mean by “throwing spaghetti” and no one laughs.

    • Nanaya says:

      I think a lot of it is more the “jingle your keys in different ways until it laughs” approach. Some of the key-jingling was great, mind you, but it only works for so long or is cut short and never seen again.

  • Moogy says:

    boy mistaken radicals are really funny

    you know the writer is being a lazy fuck when they resort to kanji “jokes”

  • Happy says:

    I never seen anime try so hard.

  • Nanaya says:

    http://blog.seiha.org/images2/sco5/sco5_30.jpg

    I will never understand the appeal to that. Seriously, is it that hard for them to clean their own damn ears?

    …And am I the only one who has issues with letting someone shove a stick through my head?