Batman: Under the Red Hood — Shut Up, Dick

July 27th, 2010

 

Teen Titans Dick is so the only good one.

It’s been pretty quiet in the western world of animation for awhile. I’m still looking forward to both Tartakovsky’s Sym-Bionic Titan and the spectacular (har de har har) Weisman’s Young Justice. Rex is still on break, and while the comedies (Futurama and Adventure Time) are going well, there’s definitely a comic action void. Oh well, I’m looking forward to these shows finally manifesting.

Impressions:

This is an adaptation of the two arcs covering the oft-ignored Jason Todd’s (the second Robin) death and revival as what essentially boils down to The Punisher. Like all of these DC features, it looks quite good for the most part. They do share Japan’s fascination with CG vehicles a little overly much. The ending fight between JT and Batman was also especially brutal. The way they handled Bruce’s memories of meeting and training JT was also pretty well handled. The ghost visions of himself were corny, but they were short, to the point, and added to the drama of the scene whenever they were dredged up.

Unfortunately, there are a few really big issues too. Nightwing (Dick Grayson/Robin 1.0) was absolutely insufferable. His dialogue was simply godawful and then he just disappeared from the entire show. Since the central theme was about raising and failing JT, you would have thought they’d at least have done something other than have Dick run around, make some awful pithy comments, then disappear, but no. The Black Mask was also a complete joke as an antagonist. The first shot of him is having his office literally covered in hockey puck-sized bugs and it only goes downhill from there. I wasn’t thrilled with this ritalined-up version of the Joker either. 

In the last 15 minutes the writing also crumbles into a number of truly bizarre deus ex machinas to hurry the plot to its end. Black Mask suddenly decides that only the Joker can fight Red Hood, which it turns out was JT’s plan all along (who says it was because only Black Mask had the resources to break him out, despite it taking nothing more than a few goons and a couple bribes). It’s par for the course for comic book villains, but that doesn’t make it any less of an ass-pull. The cops all standing around the Joker and then… sitting there while the Joker danced around and threatened to kill people… was also weird. Does Gotham PD not have snipers? Or guns? "He’s about to kill these people… EVERYBODY HOLD YOUR FIRE! But wait! There’s some other guy over there! Everybody ignore the Joker! Some guy’s standing on the bridge!"

Overall, it’s still one of the better DC Animated features to date though, about on par with their last one (Crisis on Two Earths) which I can’t remember if I covered here or not. There’ll be the obvious comparisons to the other "Joker Beats the Crap Out of a Robin" one with Beyond’s Return of the Joker, and honestly, the latter is much stronger all around. This wasn’t bad in the slightest though and is well worth your time if you’re even just a casual Batman fan.

Posted in Anime | 15 Comments »

15 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • RP says:

    Aw man, no Kevin Conroy? No Mark Hamill? Did that bother you at all?

  • Folka says:

    The villain name is actually Black Mask

  • raychel says:

    I just finished watching this tonight and thought it was one of the best Batman/DC animated films I’ve seen in a very long time. The show emphasized for me why Batman stories are always far more interesting and entertaining than any other DC character. I’m ok with the voice actors and really like hearing different takes on these iconic heroes/villains.

  • Cardinal says:

    Wouldn’t have known about this if not for your post so thanks.

    It was an awesome watch.

  • Eirias says:

    Teen Titans truly was an amazingly fun show.

    And of course the theme song is now in my head. Just great.

  • Mesousa says:

    I kinda wished you blogged Western shows, too.

    Also, since you like Adventure Time, too, what about Total Drama World Tour? I also hope you’re not too rude…

    • Aroduc says:

      I’ve caught bits and pieces of the Total Drama * every now and then. It seems okay, but aimed entirely a little bit too hard at the tweener crowd.

  • shadow says:

    dc is only batman and superman
    they ever are the proragonist in cartoon and movies
    dc only know batman and superman.

  • The Phantom says:

    This show, as every single animation done in america is garbage.

    • frog212 says:

      Simply not true. I quite enjoy Disney/Pixar animations such as Toy Story, The Incredibles and WALL-E.

    • Anonymous says:

      Don’t be biased. Sure you may prefer Japanese animation but that doesn’t mean western animation is bad.

      It’s just different people’s tastes.

  • I’m glad DC finally put out a full-length film that focuses on one of the lesser-known villains. It’s just too bad that Kevin Conroy didn’t reprise his role as Batman…