Koihime Musou #01 — Needs More Musou, Less Koi

July 8th, 2008

  

I’m also curious as to what happened to Liu Bei.

Impressions:

I’ve long held that one of the best ways to adapt a hentai game is to minimize the role of the male lead since they’re pretty much always the weakest written and the lamest character all around. It’s interesting to see a show that completely eliminates the male lead entirely, but I suppose if there’s any that could do it, something based on the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is probably strong enough on its own to manage. Then again, I haven’t played more than maybe 15 minutes of the game, but I get the strong feeling that this really isn’t a particularly close adaptation adaptation of it even without the lead. I’m not even certain how the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is supposed to survive without a Liu Bei anyway.

Instead, this seems more like the wacky adventures of Guan Yu (Kann-u, whatever). The production values are decent enough and the fight was alright, but after watching electric girls with tonfas, it lacked a certain je ne sais quais. Well, the repeated cuts to sky in the middle of the fight to show the passage of time didn’t help either. There are other complaints I could make too. The anachronistic speech patterns and cutesy Chouhi na no da got on my nerves almost immediately na no da. Chouhi as a bawling loli who then pouts is also a completely foreign concept to me na no da. The proliferation of chibis and bright/happy shouting (I can’t call that singing) in the OP and ED also doesn’t bode well for this actually having anything to do with stories I know and love instead of just being about Kann-u and Chouhi wandering around and making friends with other ‘great’ warriors.

So basically, I didn’t like this at all and I’m a whore for the Romance of the Three Kingdoms. If you’re worried about this being a hentai game adaptation, I wouldn’t sweat it in the slightest, the guy’s not even around anywhere. It really only even has a hint of the origins in the character designs themselves. Instead, it’s just low calibur wackiness with a very very very very thin and shoddy veneer of the Three Kingdoms dropped on top of it for probably a few extra sales. It’s closer to Pokemon than it is to Ikkitousen. Sure, Pokemon with a few more cleavage shots, but at least here, you’ll never see James in a bikini. There are a few hints that it’ll get a little more serious and less stupid later, but I don’t know that I’ll even last through next week, let alone however far I’d need to get for the one episode drama plot at the very end.

Koihime Musou OP

Posted in Anime | 14 Comments »

14 Shouts From the Peanut Gallery

  • Hinano says:

    Wait so there’s no lead male? What the fuck?
    Where’s my romance!
    LOL ok I think I’ll just pass without even watching ep 1.

  • Yamcha says:

    It-IT’S LU BU! What… There’s no Lu Bu yet? What a gyp. Odd as it seems, Romance of the Three Kingdoms with female characters is somehow a popular sell.

  • jeffng9 says:

    @yamcha
    i agree with u since ikkitousen is also partly adeption of romance of three kingdoms… but i feel like ikkitousen is putting way to much fan service or maybe too much!
    this one doesn’t look that bad i mean the graphic and stuff kinda cute~ and this art reminds me of RO anime.

  • Tensho says:

    I don’t even watch anyway since I hate very much cutesy, canine showing, moe, airhead anime girl (except for airhead oneesan), and show with only one sex.

  • FieryAeon says:

    You’ll be surprised at how many lolis this story is supposed to have; then again, you may not.

  • Kresnik says:

    No male protagonist? That maybe an interesting way for this anime, but maybe he just hasn’t showed up in the first ep.

  • Aroduc says:

    He’s not in the OP, ED, or listed on the cast page of the website, so I’m thinking no.

  • Tassel says:

    Personally…I was very disappointed. After being told that another H-game was being made into a series that was reminiscent of Utawarerumono, I was overjoyed. I especially liked Utawarerumono. I hope that this first ep is just more of an intro than anything else.

    Then again, I also agree that a decent male lead in a romance anime are few and hard to come by. Quite frankly, if this Lu Bu or Booboo or Frufru is just like ninety percent of all other male leads, I feel it’s better to just leave him out. I’d much rather watch an anime with a strong, independent female lead, than one with a pathetic, weak, and cowardly (but wrongly labeled as kind and patient) male lead who gets scores of hot women flocking to him, while complaining about it!

  • LDC says:

    @Tassel: well if you want strong male leads, how about watching School Days?

  • Cookie says:

    *sigh* this show has little if any promise of any thing good. When herd that this was some H-game adaptation i though, it was gonna be the typical male antaginist fighting off the females with a stick. These series are usally worth laph or two, to see how much the creatures can get away with. But this didn’t have any of that, i felt bored of this 7 minutes in. I only finished the episode in hopes “that it will get better, somehting big is gonna happen.” But it never did. This didn’t even introduce any male lead or much story for that matter. Just a bunch of fanservice and well not much else. I’ll give this series one more episode to see if it worth watching. So far its not looking good thus far.

  • Rincewind says:

    No male lead. I approve! With only girl the probability of yuri rise! :)

  • XIII says:

    Koihime Musou is a great anime that attracted because all the characters from The 3 Kingdoms had changed to females. But as I watch along,it becomes a extremely ecchi & yuri anime. I also heard that in future episode,the war started because of Sou Sou wanted Kannu,that triggered the war.

  • yuri says:

    Being a huge fan of yuri, this show is really awesome even though it is full of filler episodes and no real over-arching plot. For yuri-fans, I think we need to take all we can get. Unfortunately, there are not a lot of good yuri shows out there. Removing the male lead was the best thing. For those of you who wanted a male lead, there is no dearth of harem anime and anime in general that has male characters and male-centric plots. Best to look elsewhere. Watch episode 4 if you want to see Sousou try to get it on with Kanu. She gets a little piece of Kanu before they’re intruded but vows to pursue kanu.

  • Anonymous says:

    Kuan Yü’s long beard turning into long, beautiful black hair is hilarious, though. And Ts’ao Ts’ao’s buttering him up turning into sleeping with him..er..her is awesome…